Kinkaid+KS+–+Layne+Kirshon+&+Craig+Smyser+neg

Judge:
Aff = African Bridge (Freire)

Case Args:
None

Off Case Args:
Standards: Limits & Brightline Standards: Limits, Predictability & Brightline Uq: LOST will pass Canadian Press '8 [“Arctic boundary dispute may be heating up,” March 16, 2008, http://www.ctvottawa.ca/servlet/an/plocal/CTVNews/20070520/arctic_070520/20070520/?hub=OttawaHome] Canada's unresolved Arctic boundary ... will pass this Congress.” Link – foreign aid costs political capital Institute for International Economics 05 [The Politics of U.S. Foreign Aid, 2005, http://www.iie.com/publications/chapters_preview/321/3IIE2911.pdf] In recent years, the ... voting for foreign aid. Political capital key to passage NYT March 16 [Howard Salter, Citizens for Global Solutions, “Ratify the Law of the Sea”] One key solution, as ... planet and its people. Impact-- a. LOST key to enviro"nmental protection Sandalow 05 [David, “Law of the Sea Convention: Should the U.S. Join,” Brookings Institute] The ocean environment is ... state and seagoing nation. b. Environemtnal destruction culminates in extinction Diner, '94 Text: The National Institute of Health should approve all non-research portions of the grant request of Africa Bridge for the building of an AIDS prevention and treatment infrastructure to Tanzania. C/P competes: We PIC out of the approval of the research aspects of the grant – any perm would be severance Net benefit: NIH puts terms and conditions on every grant award NIH 2003 (http://grants.nih.gov/grants/policy/nihgps_2003/NIHGPS_Part4.htm#_Toc54600071 NIH Grants Policy Statement) As stated throughout the ... “Administrative Requirements—Monitoring—Reporting”). NIH research on AIDS drugs use Placebo trials, deliberately denying peeople of effective treatment for “science.” These trials are the unethical reseult of the plan's sepcification of “research.” Peter Lurie September 18, 1997 (Volume 337:853-856 Number 12 Unethical Trials of Internventions to Reduce Perinatal Transmission of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus in Developing Countries) It has been almost ... expose subjects to risk.”10 This is analogous to the Tuskegee syphilis experiments. The use of placebo trials are racist and subordinate concern for human beings for progress, turns the aff. Marcia Angell, M.D. 1997 (The New England Journal of Medicine Volume 337:847-849 September 18, 1997 Number 12 The Ethics of Clinical Research in the Third World) An essential ethical condition ...local standard of care.”8 On caselist—new link Capitalism = Root cause of AIDS epidemic Revolutionary Worker, 2000 (“Imperialism and AIDS in Africa,” [|http://www.rwor.org/a/v22/1060-69/1065/aids.htm)]
 * T – PHA =/= Infrastructure**
 * T – PHA = Gov't to Gov't**
 * LOST D/A**
 * CP: Exclude Placebos**
 * Capitalism K**

Block Strategy:
2NC kicks Capitalism K & LOST D/A, goes for CP 1NR goes for both T – Gov't to Gov't

2nr Strategy:
Answers residual args on Cap and T Goes for CP

Kinkaid KS – Negative

NIETZSCHE

Reznick 04 (David, "A Critique of the AIDS Metanarrative") "All human life…disease itself"

Kain 07 /Phillip J, "Nietzsche, Eternal Recurrence, and the Horror of Existence" The Jorunal of Nietzsche Studies, 33(2007) 49-63/ One might find…meaninglessness of existence

Bruckner 86 /Pascal, "Tears of the White Man: Compassion as Contempt" p65-70/ That is the wellspring…responsible

Generic Der Derian 98

Owen and Ridley 200 /David, Why Nietzsche Still?, p149-51/

Brackner 86 /The Dangers of Self hatred/

Phillips 98 /Anita, A Defense of Masochism, p151-4/

CAP K

The add is a fundamental forfeiture of our ethicao-political responsibility to confront the material biolence of modern capitalism, trading revolutionary politics for pragmatic accomplishes neither and makes true social change impossible. You should reject the aff in favor of departure from capitalist democracy. -Zizek, 2002, Revolution at the gates p. 74

The aff's benevolence toward Africa is a means of guilt assuaging. Their charity makes us all more comfortable and complacent economic relations that garauntee africa's exploitation. Zizek, "Nobdy has to be Vile" London Review of Books, Vol. 28, No. 7

Link – The affirmative's ironic mocking is the essence of modern fetishism, it does not represent some radical detachment form the system but is precisely what capitalism needs to function.

Capitalism makes death inevitable – their claims to the contrary are lies – history is on our side Internationalist Perspective, 2000 "Capitalism and Genoceide", Internationalist Perspective, #36, Spring

Do not give into the impulse to prioritize survival over meaningful social change. Capitalism has historically exploited. Ironically it is just the urge to pursue survival in the face of everything decent that puts all life on earth on the brink of extinction.

ALTERNATIVE: Reject the affirmative and withdraw from the ideology of capitalism. The affirmative will amount to nothing more than a facile call to act in a way that reproduces the existing order. There is no roadmap away from capitalism but we must bwing with outright rejection of its more covert manifestations, i.e. the aff. Only sacrificing the strategies for political change most dear to us enables space for thinking and acting differently. Zizek 2004, Iraq: The Borrowed Kettle, 769-87

And Glyn Saly, Conversations with Zizek, p. 14-19